Blog Layout

The Questions of a Quota System to See more Women on Boards

Winsome Bernard • March 8, 2016

The theme of International Women’s Day 2016 is ‘Pledge For Parity’. It is a call to action for every man and woman to commit to taking a real step towards helping to achieve gender parity in whatever way we can – whether it is helping women and girls achieve their ambitions, developing more flexibility in the workplace, allowing women to return to work, promoting women in leadership roles, and of course pay parity.


Over the years the movement toward gender parity has been rather like a foxtrot slow: slow, quick, quick, slower. The World Economic Forum predicted in 2014 that it would take until 2095 to achieve global gender parity. Then one year later in 2015, they estimated that a slowdown in the already glacial pace of progress meant the gender gap wouldn’t close entirely until 2133.

International Women’s Day was first observed on the 8th March in 1914. British suffragette leader Sylvia Pankhurst was arrested in front of Charing Cross station on her way to speak in Trafalgar Square in London.



International Women’s Day was celebrated for the first time by the United Nations in 1975. Then in December 1977, it was agreed for the United Nations Day for Women’s Rights and International Peace to be observed on any day of the year by Member States, in accordance with their historical and national traditions.

This International Women’s Day we do indeed have much to celebrate but we still have a long way to go. I want to focus on the issue of women on boards, or rather the lack of them, and how we get to something that reasonably represents the gender balance in the general population.


Elizabeth Proust, on her appointment as chair of the Australian Institute of Company Directors (AICD), has set 2018 as the deadline for 30 % of board positions in the nation’s top 200 companies to be filled by women. And whilst not previously being in favour of using quota’s to achieve these targets, she sent a message to companies that if they don’t act then they may eventually be required to by government legislation.


But there has been some progress. According to an ASIC report on the 31st January 2016 43% of all new board appointments were women, up from the 22% for same time in 2012.[3] And the latest percentage of women on ASX 200 boards is 21.9% a whopping increase from 2009 when that figure was 8.3%


There is plenty of debate out there for and against using quotas, but the conversation is not that simple and needs to acknowledge a range of issues. These include the availability of child care so that women can return to work if they want to as well as providing a flexible family friendly work place, giving equal opportunity to allow women to progress their careers. As Sheryl Sandberg COO of Facebook puts it, it is about women gaining the confidence and belief in themselves to “lean in.” Organisations must also focus on creating an executive pipeline, one that recognises the skills and talents of female employees and what they bring to the table, providing mentoring and training opportunities.


Those that disagree with quotas argue that chairs of companies and recruiters just need to look harder, that there are candidates out there, and that we just need to break the cycle and create role models for others to follow on. Others argue that quotas will simply correct existing discrimination.


There are some lessons to be learnt from Norway about board quotas. In 2003 Norway passed laws requiring companies to have 40% women company board members by 2006. Their rate of women on boards is currently 35.5%. Whilst not 40% it’s pretty impressive compared to Germany (20%), USA (17%), Australia (22%), and Japan (3%).


The arguments initially raised against quotas in Norway were: lack of suitably qualified women, interfering with the market forces, and a top down focus rather than a bottom up approach. Indeed the move did initially create a lack of women in positions just under the board level, thereby reducing the availability of women to follow on. However 10 years on, the legal requirement for quotas in Norway is now a non-issue.


Germany this year passed laws on quotas of 30% rising to 50% by 2018. They may have a woman Prime Minister in Angela Merkel, but none of the top 30 German companies have a women CEO.


For all the talk of tokenism and appointments for numbers rather than talent, quotas would be a quicker and more effective way to address gender imbalance on boards, particularly if it is accompanied by other initiatives to modify workplace culture. It’s by no means a perfect solution but we have spent a lot of years trying to encourage change, and perhaps it’s time for action.

[1] International Women’s Day. 2016. Accessed 6/2/16, via http://www.internationalwomensday.com/Theme


[2] ABC News. 2015. Quotas may be needed to boost female representation. Accessed 6/2/16, via http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-12-16/quotas-may-be-needed-to-boost-female-board-representation/7032310


[3]Australian Institute of Company Directors. 2016. Accessed 6/3/15 via, http://www.companydirectors.com.au/director-resource-centre/governance-and-director-issues/board-diversity/statistics

By Soumaya Benyassine May 24, 2022
Job candidates are more mindful of what they need and want when choosing an employer. With that, companies need to be more aware of what those preferences are so they can attract, engage, hire, and retain these talents. To win top talents, it is important to fully understand what candidate care and client experience mean
By Philip Divilly November 1, 2021
Taking care of our mental health is important inside and outside the office. According to the National Health Survey 2017 – 2018, 1 in 5 Australians reported having mental health or behavioural condition. Here in New South Wales, 17.7% of adults 18-years of age and over “experienced high or very high levels of psychological distress & hellip
By Philip Divilly September 20, 2021
To recruiters and employers out there, mastering candidate care is non-negotiable in the future of work. Candidates are looking for more meaningful interactions they believe and see, which is of great value for them. The big question or challenge now is, how can candidate care be more strategic than they are today? Candidate care more & hellip
By Philip Divilly August 10, 2021
According to the 2018 Australia’s Digital Pulse report by Deloitte, Australia’s ICT workforce will grow to more than 750,000 professionals and over 3 million Aussies will be employed in jobs with ICT functions or integrations by 2023. That projection is very much possible with what we are seeing today in the ICT and tech industry.
By Philip Divilly July 5, 2021
The war for talent rages on. It is getting harder and harder to find the right talent for the right role at the right time. Several organisations are incorporating technology to improve their recruitment capabilities in terms of quality and time of hire. Some hiring teams are spending thousands of dollars to integrate AI in & hellip
By Philip Divilly June 16, 2021
Can you recall your first job interview ever? Some people can, while for others, the image is a bit blurry. First-ever job interviews can either be memorable or forgettable because of right or wrong reasons. But, it is always a great learning opportunity even if you didn’t get the job. Today, there are thousands, maybe
By Quay Appointments June 11, 2021
Have you done an audit on your e-mail address lately? I don’t mean opening up your account and looking for messages. I mean taking a closer look at the actual e-mail address you are using. I have received a number of e-mails from some very interesting address names lately. That being said, if you were …
By Philip Divilly May 25, 2021
It’s been more than a year now of living with the pandemic right outside our doors. The struggle is indeed real as we witnessed Covid-19 caused massive upheaval across our entire operation here at Quay Appointments. As recruiters continue to push through, it is important to pay attention to opportunities to improve ourselves, to learn & hellip
By Philip Divilly May 17, 2021
Where do you see yourself in 5 years?” This is a common job interview question. If I were to ask you again, where do you see yourself 5 years from now? Or maybe even 30 years from now? The answers we often hear for this question are hopeful and optimistic. Some people tend to focus
By Philip Divilly April 21, 2021
According to the latest labour force report by the Australian Bureau of Statistics, there are more than 770,000 people unemployed in Australia as of March 2021. All those people, if not, most of them are in the job hunt. That is actually an improvement as the unemployment rate went down to 5.6% by March. Employment
More Posts
Share by: